Sign up for free to unlock exclusive discounts of 10% off or more on stays.
9
Wonderful226 reviews
meghanrooneyrecommends

Montauk Yacht Club

32 Star Island Road, Montauk, 11954, United States

from $719 per night
Hotel
Beach
Private Beach
Restaurant
Romantic
Resort
meghanrooneyrecommends
from $719 per night

About the stay

Introducing a new chapter for a storied East End social club at the expansive Montauk Yacht Club, a luxury seaside resort & marina spanning 16 acres on Montauk’s Star Island. Located on Lake Montauk & home to the Hamptons’ largest marina, the property holds eight decades of legacy—and this season will welcome a holistic refresh for the modern traveler, with operations & management led by the award-winning team behind Proper Hospitality. Merging world-class hospitality, waterfront beauty, and outdoor adventure, new additions include acclaimed on-site dining from Ocean Club restaurant & bar; refreshed guest rooms & historic villas; and elevated, one-of-a-kind wellness offerings. Across the resort, 106 stylish & spacious guest rooms and historic villas offer private patios & balconies, Lake Montauk views, and interior design bridging classic East Coast architecture, well-appointed details, and amenities that embrace the “barefoot luxury” lifestyle. The new Ocean Club restaurant & bar, led by Chef Jarad McCarroll, will offer an exciting destination for elevated indoor-outdoor dining, gatherings, and events on the East End. With menus spotlighting just-caught seafood, local produce, and shareable fare cooked over a wood-and-coal fire, the spacious restaurant will feature an open concept kitchen framed by stunning waterfront views. Across the expansive property, elevated amenities cater to the immersive waterfront surroundings and access to natural beauty, including new wellness-focused offerings; state-of-the-art fitness equipment, an all-day takeaway café, three pools (1 indoor), indoor & outdoor bars, padel, tennis courts, a private beach, and 228 wet slips that can accommodate boats from small day cruisers to 300-foot superyachts. Altogether, Montauk Yacht Club offers a unique haven for global travelers, locals, and a wide-reaching community of boating enthusiasts—welcoming a new generation of guests to experience Montauk’s distinct legacy, waterfront adventure, and endless natural beauty.

What you will find here

Restaurant(s)
Coffee shop
Private Beach
balcony/terrace
Fitness center
Spa services
Fitness classes
Laundry services
24-hour security
Electric vehicle charging station
Key access
Daily Housekeeping
Free Wi-Fi
Non-smoking property
Non-Smoking Rooms Available
Stay Details
  • Check in: 16:00
  • Check out: 11:00
Safety
  • Security 24h
from $719 per night
Unlock exclusive member discountsSign up for free

Recommendations and reviews

meghanrooneyrecommends
8.5
Excellent
Michellefamily with young children
4
Disappointing
Aug 2025
Lovely location but sadly didn't...

On the plus side....beautiful location in Montauk and appreciate the upleveled styling (along the lines of Soho House by sea :). We had breakfast and dinner at the hotel which were both good.

On the downside....imho it's a 4* hotel charging 5* prices which makes it hard to live up to expectations. Our room was OK/average - view of the car park which felt disappointing given the price of nearly £1,000 per night and erratic aircon which kept switching off. Rooms also very poorly soundproofed and we could clearly hear the group of girls partying next door until the early hours. Pool service incredibly slow - waited 45 mins for each drink and when we tried to get them at the bar we were told we had to go back and wait for poolside service. The $100 per day amenities fee also includes use of the pool - I'd expect that for additional offerings (bikes, paddleboards) but not use of the pool!

Honeyyoung couple
10
Exceptional
Aug 2025
Perfect stay

Wonderful property !

I loved everything

Miragroup
10
Exceptional
Jul 2025
Exceptional
Minafamily with young children
10
Exceptional
Jul 2025
Luxury

Location, cleanliness and the vibe

Restaurant over priced for the meals and the portions in particular!

Anonymousyoung couple
10
Exceptional
Jul 2025
Exceptional
Darynayoung couple
10
Exceptional
Jul 2025
Exceptional
Shaynayoung couple
8
Very Good
Jul 2025
Very good

beautiful property, but do wish there was more to do.

The staff was rude- for a hotel this expensive there should be more attentive staff. Also lots of billing mistakes. Still waiting for my deposit to get given back to me No Gluten free food options at restaurant

Théogroup
9
Wonderful
Jul 2025
Superb
How room selection works?

Explore our expansive selection of rooms available below with exclusive discounts, so you can feel good about your booking and make the most of your travels.

Explore our expansive selection of rooms available below with exclusive discounts, so you can feel good about your booking and make the most of your travels.

Details

1 King Bed

1 room

356 sq feet

BenefitsGuestsPrice

Room only

Non-refundable

$719 per night
$719.00total + taxes and fees

Room only

Non-refundable

$719 per night
$719.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$719.00 per night
$719.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$719.00 per night
$719.00total + taxes and fees
Details

1 King Bed

1 room

356 sq feet

BenefitsGuestsPrice

Room only

Non-refundable

$749 per night
$749.00total + taxes and fees

Room only

Non-refundable

$749 per night
$749.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$749.00 per night
$749.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$749.00 per night
$749.00total + taxes and fees
Details

2 Double Beds

1 room

356 sq feet

BenefitsGuestsPrice

Room only

Non-refundable

$819 per night
$819.00total + taxes and fees

Room only

Non-refundable

$819 per night
$819.00total + taxes and fees

Room only

Non-refundable

$819 per night
$819.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$819.00 per night
$819.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$819.00 per night
$819.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$819.00 per night
$819.00total + taxes and fees
Details

1 King Bed

1 room

356 sq feet

BenefitsGuestsPrice

Room only

Non-refundable

$1,019 per night
$1,019.00total + taxes and fees

Room only

Non-refundable

$1,019 per night
$1,019.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$1,019.00 per night
$1,019.00total + taxes and fees
Benefits

Room only

Non-refundable

Guests per room
$1,019.00 per night
$1,019.00total + taxes and fees
Montauk Yacht Club: Deals on recommended stays